Discussion about this post

User's avatar
MC's avatar
Apr 1Edited

Giants fans received a gift when Shildt left. The Kapler vs Melvin vibes that permeated 2024-2025, especially by Baggs, who sets the tone for coverage. Melvin would help the Giants prepare by Standing for the Anthem vs Kapler. The best sports writer is Kevin Acee.

Pay for a subscription to SD U-T and most importantly, sign up for Padres Daily. You’ll learn more about how to evaluate baseball and a sports season. Every journalist should sign up too. PhD education. This is how you cover a team. Baseball is a business: https://www.sandiegouniontribune.com/2026/04/01/padres-daily-not-pretty-stammens-patience-back-of-the-rotation-blues-laureano-left-out/

The Shildt vs Stammen vibes are strong. Only 5 games into the season, but so far Stammen has weak attention to details, players aren’t prepared: game planning, fundamentals and mental mistakes. Padres lost 2-3 winnable games w/ Tigers and Giants.

When Eno Sarris said “eyewash wins” on Opening Day 2024, everyone in the Giants organization, including Posey, ignored it: Board member + more importantly as POBO. The same eyewash in SD by Melvin and his staff. The funniest shit is Dave Flemming, who is super smart, told the Friar Territory pod that it was a weakness Melvin had the same staff for so long, but Posey escapes any accountability. Ditto most fans and media.

Melvin is so loved by the media no one wants to tarnish his legacy: 2025 Giants, and most especially, 2023 Padres, are manager malpractice: exact same results with 3 different FO, rosters and the highest payroll in Padres franchise history.

SD fans, local, national media, including Pavs and Shea, said Shildt couldn’t get the Padres to the World Series. Nor did Melvin’s loaded A’s or Padres. Nor has Murphy, who is charismatic, high energy. Brewers swept the Dodgers in the regular season with the best record in baseball: swept postseason by Dodgers, offense cold. WBC + MLB postseason prove that any offense can shut down with “built to win now” rosters when a championship is on the line.

No posts

Ready for more?