Discussion about this post

User's avatar
MC's avatar
3hEdited

Your National Park tour is gold!

How are smart people not understanding the Devers trade? Statue contracts = players that take a team to the playoffs every year. Full stop. @gggiants and others are wrong in how they’re evaluating 1/2 billion contracts. Posey is expected to evaluate talent better than the Red Sox or Braves (Dom Smith).

Did Wotus, Bochy tell Posey not to hire a college coach or 3B coach with no MLB experience?!

The Rockies are 1/2 game above the Giants. Posey’s decision-making is a 3-alarm fire and his internal council are Yes Men.

Kerry said Murphy and Vogt would want to work for Posey if they could get out of their contracts. NO! Why would they sign extensions if they thought Tony V wouldn’t work out.

Kerry say’s Valkyries must make playoffs or bust, prove talent can improve and win a playoff round, but moves goal posts for Giants with SF Standard coverage he oversees. I’m worried Kerry will be the fall guy in the Standard’s hot mess of how they’re evaluating Melvin vs Tony V and Posey vs Zaidi and the Giants vs Valkyries.

Stephen La Porta's avatar

Welcome back and well said friend. Have a blast at Wrigley. I grew up there. Re the trade, some folks want to say that 99.9% would have endorsed the trade at the time. Thing is, that's not how we evaluate moves -- not at what seemed right at the time, but instead on what the tangible real results turn out to be. And right now, the pace that Devers is on vs. the one that Harrison is on for 2036 doesn't bode well.

No posts

Ready for more?