Discussion about this post

User's avatar
MC's avatar
May 14Edited

Excellent capture of Kershaw, Ohtani.

Giants are just the 10th team to start the season 0-3, scoring 1 or fewer runs, swept by the Yankees. None of the previous teams made playoffs. Smart beat writers, columnists and fans noted the Brewers started 2025 swept by the Yankees. The Brewers scored more runs.

I’m terrible at math and I ramble but I moved the Giants out of playoff contention when they won the Nationals series, losing 3-0 in the rubber match. Unless Giants catch lightning in the bottle, all the underlying metrics show otherwise.

Every NL Central team is above .500 and the scuffling NL East teams look stronger than the Giants. D-Backs are resilient.

More notably than Ohtani imho is the Giants were shut out for the 8th time; 9 in 1976.

When Posey panicked (again) sending Bailey packing, I wondered if the Giants would reach 70 wins. Maybe this will age horribly, but I do not think “a college coach with no professional baseball experience prior to this season” is an issue managing the Giants 1/2 billion: Adames, Devers, Chapman. Giants had same issues with a 3x MoY with decades of pro experience. Chapman ran into an out vs the Dodgers. Adames made a mistake that helped cost a win in a 1-run loss vs the Dodgers. Bailey and Chapman had a mixup in LA. Devers swung for the fences and struck out vs taking a walk, sac fly or hit under Melvin.

“Posey has publicly stated his distain for fraternization between opponents,” than he should never have signed Adames or Arráez. Posey is erratic in his decision-making process. If Flau’jee Johnson becomes a star, it will not be a “permanent stain” on the Valkyries decision-making process. Future success is driven more on having a clear Identity vs making decisions based on what fans, beat writers, columnists want: Melvin, Posey, long-term contracts to stars, lineup card changes, Eldridge, catchers.

Ack pfft's avatar

Connor… Connor? We haven’t heard from you in a while although not much can be said right now. Are you lost somewhere in this wasteland of Giants baseball?

No posts

Ready for more?